For sale · Mixed use

Umatilla Colonial Building

9 North Central Avenue, Umatilla, FL 32784

$2.60MPricing from listing brokerContact listing team
Umatilla Colonial Building1 of 1
Listing media supplied by the listing team
Property typeMixed use
Building / lot20,382 SF
Investment7.7% cap
UpdatedNov 8, 2026

About this property

Located in the heart of downtown Umatilla, Florida, the Umatilla Colonial Building is a 20,382 square foot mixed-use asset strategically positioned at 9 North Central Avenue. The property features a complementary blend of retail and residential uses, creating a diversified income profile within a walkable live-work-play environment. Following a substantial renovation and repositioning, the asset is now fully stabilized, offering investors the opportunity to acquire a refreshed, income-producing property with both historic charm and modern functionality. The extensive improvements have significantly enhanced the building’s appeal, operational stability, and long-term value. Umatilla Colonial Building is a 20,382-square-foot mixed-use property located at 9 North Central Avenue in Umatilla, FL. On-site parking, as well as an included 50yr adjacent parking ground lease provides ample commercial and residential spaces. Over $500,000 in CapEx improvements in the past four years.

Property highlights

Mixed-Use Investment
Investment snapshot

Financial overview

Net operating income
$200,000
Capitalization rate
7.69%

Financial information is supplied by the listing team. Review the offering documents and independently verify all figures.

Property record

Building and site details

Building size
20,382 SF
Year built
1922
Zoning
Commercial
County
Lake
Location

Explore the property area

Loading interactive location map…

9 North Central AvenueUmatilla, FL 32784

Get directions

Map position is based on listing coordinates. Confirm access, entrances, and boundaries with the listing team; the marker is not a parcel survey.

Quick underwriting

Test the investment assumptions

Published NOI. This field starts with the listing team's published annual NOI. Any edits are your own assumptions.

Calculated cap rate7.69%
Annual debt service$165,386
Estimated DSCR1.21×
Cash flow after debt$34,614
Cash-on-cash return5.33%

Estimates exclude closing costs, reserves, taxes and changes to operating expenses. This is not financial advice.

Due diligence

Documents

Loading secure document access…
Listing transparency

Know where the information came from.

Last updated
Nov 8, 2026
Broker status
Verification pending
Marketplace integrity

Report Umatilla Colonial Building

Complete the verification check before submitting.

Explore the market

More opportunities in Umatilla.

Browse nearby commercial properties and compare opportunities in the live search.

Explore nearby properties